- Movie Review:
- Charlie Kaufman, Donal Kaufman, Spike Jonze
- Rating:
- 4
Summary:
In 'Adaptation' Charlie Kaufman struggles to adapt the book 'The Orchid Thief' by Susan Orlean into a film.
Adaptation: the action or process of adapting or being adapted.
Adaptation is one of the movies on my list of films that I never expected to watch, let alone review. But here I am, writing a review of a film I thought I never watch. A dear friend and I have this ongoing conversation about Nicolas Cage, and his mediocre acting skills. He believes that Cage is under-appreciated; and I think that Cage as an actor, for lack of a better word–stinks. See, Cage is on my list of actors whose films I would never watch simply because these actors are in it (It’s a pretty short list - Eva Mendez is also on the list, so is William Shatner), however, that is another post for another time. Straight away, I found that Adaptation would be unlike the other deleterious films I’ve seen Cage star in (Sorcerer’s Apprentice) just to name one. Instead, Adaptation is one of those movies that for me, came altogether and unexpectedly enjoyable.
Adaptation is an adaptive comedy about screenwriter Charlie Kaufman (Cage) and his screenwriting fictitious brother Donald Kaufman (also played by Cage). He was hired to adapt a screenplay about Susan Orlean‘s (Meryl Streep) book The Orchid Thief–based on John Laroche (Chris Cooper), who was arrested in Florida for allegedly poaching rare orchids in the Fakahatchee Strand State Preserve, while working with Seminole Indians. The film begins where Being John Malkovich ends–with Charlie shuffling around in the distance, obscuring a shot. He is the creator of the script, originator of the film, and the reason everyone is there filming–but no one realizes who he is or his reason for being there.
The Orchid Thief is a straightforward, and literal story, however, Charlie is troubled with converting the book into a drama worthy of Hollywood’s big-screen audiences. He instead wrote the script about himself, a screenwriter–who could not find a way to adapt the book, into a movie. The story cross-cuts into the scenes where Susan Orlean (Streep) is also writing her own book inspired by “orchid thief” Laroche (Cooper), who obsesses about the flowers. But Charlie isn’t aware of this part of the saga yet. He’s obsessed with his own failures. He believes that he is uninspired, fat, balding, and get super nervous around pretty women. What does this have to do about his script? Well just about everything. He is awkward around people. He said so himself, and he has concluded that’s his problem–he needed to meet Orlean. But not just yet.
What made matters worse for the mild-mannered and extremely timid Charlie Kaufman was his eccentric twin brother Donald, who stayed with him. Like Charlie, Donald decides that he wants to be a screenwriter, but his approach to the art of screenwriting is as his personality–overt and reckless; while his brother wallows in self-deprecating subconscious banter about wanting his script to be as personable, or as real as Orlean’s book. What winds up happening–Charlie is forced to face his adaptation deficiency with the help of his brother Donald.
Screenwriting is easy…not.
Donald isn’t having any trouble with his screenplay. He cranks out a 6-figured script with the greatest of ease while his brother is utterly stressing out over his script for The Orchid Thief. So he suggests that Charlie attend a screenwriting seminar by screenwriting guru Robert McKee (Brian Cox), who’s method for dramatic storytelling is structurally organized–something Charlie quite hates. Out of desperation; he takes the class, if anything, it allowed him some form of redemption; however, he doesn’t have a script yet and here is where the movie starts to “get real,” and fall into its predictable ‘Hollywood‘ manner which is expected and downright unavoidable.
As in every story there is always a “back-story,” and Donald concludes that Charlie’s problem is a straightforward one–instead of obsessing over writing a script about a woman and flowers, and he should find out more about who this woman is. He was certain that Orlean’s more intriguing than her book.
It’s supposed to be a film about flowers…
Meanwhile, Orlean is busy with her own book and obsession with Laroche, and this obsession leads into an unconventional romance filled with orchids, drugs, and resulting perpetual dilemmas. As much as Charlie wanted the film to take a more literal approach to Orlean’s book–it morphed into a decidedly different tale of deceit, attempted murder, car chases–and a man versus swamp-beast event, which was entirely opposite of his original intent for the film–which may have been the whole point of the “real” Kaufman script. The acting talents as a whole made the whole of events intense and engaging. I enjoyed the inner struggle and moral battles each character had to contend with and their attempt to overcome them.
I believe Streep’s character, Susan Orlean, summed things up best when she specifically stated “Adaptation is a film about truly lonely people and their genius.” Oftentimes, this genius creates a soul’s madness enabling its masters to partake in something more than their lonely passions: Laroche had his flowers; Orlean had her sexual liberation; Charlie, through his script resulted in the evolution of himself; and Donald–well, we didn’t have to worry too much about Donald. He did okay.
She wishes she was as shiny as an ant…right?
Overall, Adaptation is an enjoyable film, and it wasn’t good solely because of Cage’s acting performance–he wasn’t the only acting presence that carried the story. Streep, Cooper, and the rest of the all-star ensemble (Swinton, Gyllenhaal, and Cox) warrants extreme acting credits. Solely, it is the brilliant script writing by the “real” Charlie Kaufman, and the brilliant directing talent of Spike Jonze. The actors are mere complements. The character’s turmoil’s were complicated by their own genius, their own emotions, and the events that emanated from each–which served them only as a resolve from very personal, prevailing sadness.
Actors are personified only by a great script and a great director. I concede to Cage’s best acting performance in Adaptation as evidence to only that.
Adapt to survive…or something like it.
- editor rating4
AIDY
@aidyreviews
Latest posts by AIDY (see all)
- PUSSY RIOT: A PUNK PRAYER Coming Exclusively to HBO in June - 05/23/2013
- DVD Review: Pacino, Walken, Arkin in STAND UP GUYS - 05/21/2013
- Blu-Ray Review: Steven Soderbergh’s SIDE EFFECTS - 05/21/2013
Check Out:
- The Sorcerers Apprentice – Review Review of Disney's The Sorcerer's Apprentice is a Jerry Bruckheimer...
- Blu-ray Review: Snow Flower and the Secret Fan Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is a film directed by...
- Never Let Me Go – Review How would you live with the knowledge that you are...
- There Be Dragons – Review There Be Dragons is a war biography written and directed by...





I kind of have to agree with you about Nick Cage! There are a few films that he is good in, but overall, he really isn’t that great of an actor, IMO!
Our views differ, however, when it comes to this film. I watched it for an adaptation scriptwriting class I had last year and I just found it extremely difficult to get into. I found myself thinking of other things and not really paying that much attention and then the next thing I know, there’s action and other things going on and I just sat there like… “when did THAT happen?”
I liked the message of the film and the overall theme in it and I do believe that it was acted out really well but it just wasn’t a film for me. It’s a shame because the rest of my class seemed to enjoy it, and you obviously did too but yeah, it’s not one that I’d really venture out to watch again, unfortunately!
This was a great review though
And I’m glad that you got to appreciate this film, even if I didn’t!
Faye
Faye recently posted..Friday’s Film Favourite #13
Cage is a terrible actor, right up there with Shatner. I think he know that. I fell into this movie because I completely related to his character. I too suffer from an internal dialogue shaping my daily actions and in writing. I agree, the overall theme for the film were significant and the theme was spot on. I think anyone in the industry could relate to either one of the characters in the film.
Thanks Faye!
AIDY recently posted..A Beautiful Life – Review
I think you right. Probably something different for Nick Cage. Showing a little versatility that you won’t normally see in one of his usual knowing-all-the-answers rolls, on some kind of quest where he will almost certainly be victorious. Great review. I can’t wait to see the movie!
Thank you for enjoying the review. I think you will enjoy the film as well.
AIDY recently posted..‘TUNE’ by Szonja Szabo – Review
Oh yeah, I get it now! “Cameron Poe” aka Nic Cage character in “Con Air.” How dare you sir. That movie sucked as well! BIG FAT AWFUL!
So there. Put your bunny in that box and lite it on FIRE!
AIDY recently posted..A Beautiful Life – Review
Very peculiar movie (as you would expect from something written by Kaufman) and I remember being blown away by it but it’s been such a long time… I need to see this again.
Castor recently posted..The AM Movie Fantasy League Returns on February 25 – Sign Up Now! [Limited Availability]
Yes. I watched the film again today and enjoyed it more. I have ‘Being John Malkovich’ somewhere. I’m going to watch that again. It’s all thanks to my dearest Jean-Marie for sending me the film. He was right about this one. I have to give him credit for that.
AIDY recently posted..TCM Spotlight: Marlene Dietrich
I can’t say I’m a huge fan of this because I think half the film works better than the other. But the better half of the film – Cage talking to Cage trying to write a screenplay is so good the film is definitely worthwhile. That said, the performances are excellent across the board so while it isn’t up there with John Malkovich I can’t criticise it too much.
I had mixed feelings about this one. On one hand I love the invention and creativity that is always a feature of Kaufman movies. In a world dominated by LA cop buddy movies I can warm to almost anything that tries to be more ambitious. Having said that I found this a little hard to get into, and much preferred Being John Malkovich.
Oh and yes I agree about Nick Cage’s acting, except in Leaving Las Vegas, which I though he was excellent in